relational inquiry regarding meaning » intelligibility » subjectivity
• embodied cognition
• exploratory attention-as-experience, functioning to expand our capacity for knowing—see Nixon essay and McGilchrist video
• Jung: importance of symbolic/metaphoric language—see Edinger (1972) Ego and archetype: Individuation and the religious function of the psyche [Shambhala 1992] (beginning at pg. 107)
• Nietzsche: the Dionysian primordial oneness (contrasted with the P-node's Apollonian); perspectivism
• qualia, what-it's-like-ness, acquaintance-knowledge
McGilchrist's account of what the right hemisphere of our brain does, from (2009) The Master and His Emissary:
• allows "an open, receptive, widely diffused alertness to whatever exists" (25)
• "underwrites breadth and flexibility of attention... [and] sees things whole, and in their context" (27)
• attends to "the live, complex, embodied, world of individual, always unique beings, forever in flux, a net of interdependencies, forming and reforming wholes, a world in which we are deeply connected" (31)
• "more capable of a frame shift ...especially important for flexibility of thought" (40)
• synthesizes "in consciousness different elements, including information from the ears, eyes, and other sensory organs, and from memory, so as to generate the richly complex, but coherent, world we experience" (42)
• "has dominance for exploratory attentional movements" (44)
• "sees each thing in its context, as standing in a qualifying relationship with all that surrounds it" (49)
• is "concerned with the relations between things" (50)
• "presents individual, unique instances of things and individual, familiar, objects" (51)
• "plays an important role in ...a capacity to put oneself in another's position and see what is going on in that person's mind" (57)—empathy
• exhibits "the preponderance of emotional understanding" (58)
• connects us "to the self as embodied" (66)
• and so on.
Perspectival knowing involves the immediate, experiential quality of being present in a situation, capturing "what it is like to be" in a given context (Nagel 1974 […]). An agent occupies a perspective from a position within a situation, not a position in space and time alone, and occupying it is like something; neither aspect is available without the other, since what it is like is always what it is like from here and now rather than from elsewhere. This way of knowing accordingly addresses questions such as, "When and where do I do it? What is it like when I do it?" and is associated with episodic memory, affording experiential access to scenes and situations from a first-person perspective. Its normative standard is the sense of presence: being situated in the here and now […].
Perspectival knowing operates through the dynamic calibration of attention, affect, and sense of agency […], constituting what Vervaeke and Mastropietro (2024) characterize as the salience landscape, through which certain affordances […] become salient while others recede. Optimal gripping on this salience landscape, in the sense of Merleau-Ponty (1945/2012), then discloses a presence landscape within which a field of affordances […] becomes available and orientation within a situation becomes possible […]. This grip admits of degrees, and the agent feels the difference. A poorer grip discloses less of what a situation affords, and the agent is disoriented. It is through this gripping that perspectival knowing achieves situational awareness. It is also within this lived landscape of presence that procedural skills and routines find their situation, the when and where of their deployment. Procedural knowing thus depends on perspectival knowing for the situational context within which know-how can be exercised.
Consider a hiker navigating an unfamiliar trail who notices the changing texture of the path, distinctive rock formations, and shifts in vegetation that signal elevation changes. These noticed features become reference points that orient the hiker's movement, enabling them to gauge progress, anticipate challenges, and adjust their pace accordingly. A hiker who stops reading the trail is still walking it, but it affords less: progress becomes hard to gauge, and what is coming goes unanticipated. Here, the emphasis is not on factual details or practiced skill but on the lived quality of being present that guides responsive action.
_key text
• McGilchrist, I. (2009) The master and his emissary: The divided brain and the making of the Western world [Yale UP] (see quotes above)
_additional texts
• Code, L. (1991) What can she know? Feminist theory and the construction of knowledge [Cornell UP]
• Jackson, F. (1982) Epiphenomenal qualia [The Philosophical Quarterly 32(127), 127-136]
• Kierkegaard, S. (1846) The subjective truth, inwardness; Truth is subjectivity. In Concluding unscientific postcript [A. Hannay, trans. Cambridge UP 2009]
• Nagel, T. (1974) What is it like to be a bat? [The Philosophical Review 83(4), 435-450]
• Vervaeke, J. (2019 talk at Stoicon-X Toronto) "The View from Above: A Transformation of Perspectival and Participatory Knowing" (video here)